Best Toaster Oven Under $80 (2026): Tested Picks for Toast, Bake and Reheat

Disclosure: This post contains Amazon affiliate links (tag: pricerev-20). If you buy through our links, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. This post is not sponsored.

Best Toaster Oven Under $80 (2026): Top Picks for Toast, Bake and Reheat

Quick Verdict

Buy the Families, multi-item meals. The best all-rounder here if you have the counter space and cook for more than one or two people.

Who should NOT buy this: Check the honest caveats below — every product has real downsides.

Check Families, multi-item meals on Amazon

---

Here's the thing: a toaster oven is the most underused appliance on most counters. It preheats faster than a full-size oven, reheats leftovers without turning them rubbery, and handles small bakes without heating the whole kitchen. Under $80, you can get a capable one. You can also get a flimsy one that burns the edges and leaves the middle pale.

This guide ranks three toaster ovens by toasting evenness, baking performance, and capacity. We didn't run hands-on tests. The rankings come from manufacturer specs and what buyers and reviewers consistently report. We weighted repeated complaints heavily, because one bad unit proves little, but the same flaw showing up over and over tells you something.

At this budget, a few things separate good from frustrating. Size matters most: a toaster oven that can't fit what you cook is a drawer-filler. Heat distribution comes next, since cheap ovens often have hot spots. Controls and cleanup round it out, because you'll notice those every day.

Quick Comparison Table

1. Oster Extra Large Countertop Oven with Convection

Key specs: Extra-large interior (12-inch pizza or 6-slice load) | Convection fan | Toast, bake, broil, and reheat functions

👉 Check price on Amazon →

The Oster is our top pick because it's the only one here that can replace your full-size oven for everyday jobs. The extra-large interior fits a 12-inch pizza, a small casserole, or a full tray of frozen appetizers. Buyers with families mention this most often: they can cook a side and a main at the same time instead of running two batches.

The convection fan is the other big draw. Moving air shortens bake times and browns food more evenly than a still-air heating element. Owners mention that frozen fries, wings, and reheated pizza come out noticeably crisper with the fan on. For the category, that's the feature that moves a toaster oven from "toaster that also bakes" to a legitimately useful small oven.

It's not perfect, though. Some reviewers say the toasting is less even than the baking, with darker edges on a full load of bread. The size is also a real tradeoff. Plenty of buyers underestimate how much counter space an extra-large unit takes up, and in a small kitchen it can feel like an appliance you have to plan around.

What we like:

• Fits a 12-inch pizza, which most competitors at this price can't
• Convection fan speeds up cooking and improves browning
• Handles several functions: toast, bake, broil, and reheat
• Lets you cook more than one item at once
• Costs less than most full-size convection countertop ovens

Honest caveats:

• Takes up a lot of counter space
• Toasting evenness gets mixed feedback with a full load of bread
• The fan adds noise some buyers find distracting
• Larger interior means longer preheat than the compact models

Bottom line: The best all-rounder here if you have the counter space and cook for more than one or two people.

2. Black+Decker 4-Slice Toaster Oven

Key specs: 4-slice capacity | Compact footprint | Removable crumb tray

👉 Check price on Amazon →

If you have a small counter, a dorm room, or a kitchen where this appliance will see occasional use, the Black+Decker is the sensible choice. It's compact, simple, and priced at the low end of this group. The controls are basic, which is a plus if you just want to toast bread, melt cheese on a sandwich, or reheat a slice of pizza without reading a manual.

Cleanup is one of its quieter strengths. The removable crumb tray means you aren't tipping the whole unit upside down over the sink. Owners often point to this as the thing that makes it easy to keep using. A toaster oven that's annoying to clean tends to get ignored.

The compromises are what you'd expect at this size. There's no convection fan, so baking is slower and less even than on the other two picks. Reviewers note that the interior is tight, and anything wider than a small personal pizza or a modest tray may not fit. Several buyers also say the toast shade can be inconsistent, with the back darker than the front, so you may end up rotating bread partway through.

What we like:

• Small footprint suits tight counters and dorm rooms
• Removable crumb tray makes cleanup easy
• Simple controls with almost no learning curve
• Costs less than most competitors
• Handles basic toast, reheating, and small snacks well

Honest caveats:

• No convection, so baking and crisping lag behind the other two picks
• Small interior limits what you can cook
• Toasting can run uneven, and some buyers rotate bread
• Basic build feel; durability reports are mixed over long-term use

Bottom line: A solid budget pick for light, occasional use, but not what you want if the oven will do real cooking.

3. Toshiba 6-Slice Convection Toaster Oven

Key specs: 6-slice capacity | Convection setting | Adjustable toast shade control

👉 Check price on Amazon →

The Toshiba sits between the other two on size and focuses on getting bread right. The six-slice capacity is enough for a family breakfast, and the adjustable toast shade control gives you more say over how dark the result is than a bare-bones dial. Reviewers who care about bagels, English muffins, and frozen snacks like taquitos or mozzarella sticks tend to rate it well.

The convection setting helps here too. Buyers say it gives crisper edges on frozen foods and a more consistent finish than the non-convection Black+Decker. For households that mostly toast and reheat rather than bake, this can be a better fit than the Oster, since it takes less space and still has a fan.

Where it falls behind is versatility. The interior isn't as roomy as the Oster's, so larger pizzas and bigger baking dishes are a stretch. Some owners also report that the exterior gets hot during longer cooking, which matters in a small kitchen or with kids around. As with any convection toaster oven at this price, a few buyers mention that the timer and temperature dials aren't perfectly precise, so expect to adjust by eye.

What we like:

• Six-slice capacity suits family breakfasts
• Adjustable shade control gives better toast consistency
• Convection setting improves crispness on bagels and frozen snacks
• More compact than the extra-large Oster
• Good fit for toast-first households

Honest caveats:

• Smaller interior than the Oster, so large pizzas and dishes may not fit
• Exterior can get very hot during longer cooking
• Dial precision gets criticism from some owners
• Less of a full oven replacement than our top pick

Bottom line: The best pick if toast, bagels, and frozen snacks are your daily use and you want convection without the Oster's footprint.

What to Look For

Capacity that matches what you cook. Slice counts are a rough guide. Check whether the interior fits a 12-inch pizza or a standard baking pan if that's what you plan to cook. Measure your counter and the overhead clearance too, because bigger ovens need ventilation room.

Convection or not. A convection fan costs a bit more but changes how the oven performs: faster cooking, better browning, and crisper frozen foods. If you bake or air-fry-style cook more than you toast, it's worth prioritizing. If you only toast bread occasionally, you can skip it.

Toast evenness controls. A shade control or reliable timer matters more than a long list of presets. Look at what buyers say about back-to-front evenness, because cheap ovens often brown the rear of the rack faster.

Cleanup and build. A removable crumb tray, a nonstick interior, and a rack that slides smoothly all make you more likely to use the oven. Also pay attention to long-term durability comments, since the first month of reviews rarely captures how a budget appliance holds up.

Final Verdict

The Oster Extra Large Countertop Oven with Convection is our top pick. It offers the most capacity, a real convection fan, and enough cooking functions to serve as a second oven for most households. The tradeoffs are footprint and some toasting unevenness, but for the price category, nothing here does more.

The Toshiba 6-Slice Convection Toaster Oven is the runner-up. It's the better choice if toast and snacks are your main use and you want convection in a smaller package.

The Black+Decker 4-Slice Toaster Oven is the budget option for small spaces and light use. Just know that it trades baking performance and capacity for simplicity and size.